A pizza establishment co-located with Surfside Subs in Long Beach, Gloucester, known for its pizzas and participating in 'Monday Madness' deals.
Insights
ItalianPizzaAmericanLunchDinnerCasual
Last updated: 9/16/2026, 3:13:09 AM
Key Information
Killer Pizza is a pizza joint located in St. Petersburg, Florida, known for its New York-style pizzas. They offer takeout and delivery services.
Customer Perception
Customers generally praise Killer Pizza for its delicious pizza, with some highlighting it as the best in St. Pete. The restaurant is noted for its customizable options and New York-style crust.
Additional Details
The restaurant's address is 1156 94th Ave N, St. Petersburg, FL 33702. They have a presence on Facebook and Yelp, and their menu is available for order through getsauce.com.
Operating hours suggest lunch and dinner are available Tuesday through Sunday. Specific peak times are not detailed, but it's likely busiest during typical meal hours.
We ordered delivery - Cheese calzone, garlic knots, wings and a pizza 🍕. I'm so happy they are near us! My hubby loves them wings and he is NOT under the influence. They're the best wings he ever had! Annnnnywho, this dinner was delicious and we're definitely going to order again 😍
Amazingg pizza. Outstanding service. I love this place. I’m originally from New Jersey so it’s really hard to find good pizza down here.
Looking for a New York/New Jersey, kind of pizza is definitely the best spot I’ve been to so far 🫶🏻🖤
5
I'm no Dave Portnoy but I consider myself a big fan of NY style pizza. I've tried many places in the northeast including Boston, New York and Connecticut. There are some NY style pizza places in Tampa / St Pete that are decent, but none of them come close to that NY flavor. Killer Pizza is the closest thing to NY style you'll find in the Tampa area. Ordered 2 large slices to try and they were massive, it was basically like eating a whole personal pizza. The sauce and cheese was evenly distributed, you can tell this pie wasn't half-assed. The bottom was crispy but not burnt, and held up when you picked it up. No flop jalop or soggy undercarriage. Now I wanna try the whole menu and I'm just upset I live across the bridge in Tampa or I'd be here at least once a week. Might have to make the drive once a month regardless to get my fix. Very relaxed and comfortable environment. The owner really takes pride in his craft and it shows!!
5
This was our second time ordering from this small, local business and it was much better than the first delivery experience. After chatting w/ the owner Matt about the minor hiccup, I decided to give it another try as a pickup after work. There are a few small tables indoor and out, funky art designs on walls, and daily specials.
The Death by the Goat was pretty damn delicious w/ great consistency of sauce, goat cheese and crisp bacon on the pizza, so simple but w/ flavorful, fresh ingredients made it outstanding. The Sacred Smoke flavored dry rub wings were meaty, crisp thankfully as I forgot to order “well done”, on the side was a solid portion of Ranch. Check it out.
5
We tried Killer Pizza for the first time and we will definitely be back. We did a cheese pizza and it was huge! Our grandkids and us enjoyed it very much. We also got the meatballs and a small order of wings with the Carolina sauce and they were so good. The delivery driver was great, dressed well and very polite. I personally hate when people show up with a delivery in their pajamas. Great experience and we highly recommend.
