Don Angie

Had a great experience at Don Angie. The staff was incredibly nice and attentive, and the food was excellent. What stood out most was how unique the menu felt compared to your typical Italian restaurant. It had familiar flavors but with some really creative twists. The tiramisu was definitely a highlight and something I’d highly recommend if you’re looking to try something a little different. Overall, great food, great service, and a really memorable experience. Definitely worth checking out if you’re in New York!

This place was truly exceptional, and I felt genuinely grateful to have been able to secure a reservation. From the moment I arrived, the staff made the experience feel effortless and welcoming. They were warm, attentive, and clearly committed to making sure every detail was just right, which set the tone for an unforgettable meal. The food was on another level. The Japanese Sweet Potatoes and Buffalo Milk Carmelle were unlike anything I’ve ever tasted—bold, memorable, and absolutely masterful in execution. They weren’t just great dishes; they were the kind of standout flavors that stay with you long after the meal is over. The lasagna pinwheels were another highlight and completely lived up to the hype. Rich, flavorful, and beautifully prepared, they were a must-try in every sense. Even the bread served alongside was outstanding—soft, fresh, and finished with the perfect subtle crunch. What I appreciated most was the feeling that every part of the experience had been thoughtfully designed. It wasn’t just a dinner; it was a complete experience that felt polished, personal, and deeply satisfying. I left feeling cared for, impressed, and fully content. This is the kind of restaurant you remember, recommend, and eagerly return to.

Don Angie (New York City) Visiting Don Angie based on its intense online hype turned out to be a deeply disappointing experience. While the restaurant is frequently lauded as a destination spot, the reality fell far short of the reputation, making it a stark reminder to trust your own senses over social media trends. The atmosphere was super noisy, making it impossible to hold a conversation with friends. The service was equally frustrating; the pace was sluggish, and we endured a 40-minute wait just for the pasta course to arrive. Unfortunately, the food was the biggest letdown. A recurring, ruinous theme across every dish was an excessive amount of salt. The chrysanthemum salad was buried under so much cheese that the saltiness was overpowering. The garlic flatbread was disappointingly small and similarly over-salted. Even their signature lasagna, while visually impressive, was so aggressively salty that it left a bitter, metallic aftertaste on the tongue. Every single item we ordered suffered from this lack of balance. If you are planning to dine out in New York, be wary of the hype. Rely on your own judgment rather than curated online popularity to ensure you enjoy your meal rather than regret the reservation.

The pinwheel lasagna is the dish that built this restaurant's reputation and it holds up completely. A whole lasagna roll sliced into spirals and layered with béchamel and meat ragu, it arrives as something that looks elegant and eats like the most satisfying version of a childhood memory you could possibly conjure. The chrysanthemum salad is the order that surprises most tables, floral and bright with garlic and croutons and a dressing that makes the whole thing taste more interesting than a salad has any right to. The stuffed garlic flatbread is the thing you pull apart before anything else and immediately wish you'd ordered two of, cheesy and deeply garlicky in a way that sets the whole tone for the meal. The sourdough pasta in a spicy nduja and mezcal-braised chicken sauce is the pasta that keeps appearing on tables around you, funky and rich with that smoky undertone from the mezcal doing a quiet, important job in the background. The black cocoa tiramisu is the dessert that closes things out in a way that makes you rethink the usual version, a darker, more complex take that's clearly been thought about seriously. Walk-in seating at the bar opens at service and is the best option when reservations aren't available. The Italian Coffee Situation cocktail, their smooth riff on an espresso martini, is the right opening move for the evening.